The New England Signal
Independent journalism covering all six New England states
Maine

Maine council chair questions Main Street flag plan: 'It’s not just patriotism there, it’s something else'

A Yarmouth Eagle Scout’s plan for American flags along Main Street was approved, but only after the council chair said big flag displays can feel like more than patriotism.

The chairman of the Yarmouth Town Council pushed back last week on a plan to fly American flags along the town’s Main Street for six months of the year, saying large flag displays can suggest “something else” besides patriotism.

Council Chair David Craig made the comments at the council’s Oct. 15 meeting, during a debate over an Eagle Scout project proposed by local Scout Ian Ferguson of Troop 35. Ferguson’s plan was to install brackets on poles along Main Street and fly about 32 flags, paying for the brackets, poles and spare flags through his own fundraising.

“It doesn’t mean I’m not patriotic,” Craig said. “But honestly, when I drive through some towns that have hundreds of flags up and they’re there up all the time, it’s sort of like I feel like, well, first of all, it’s not special anymore.”

“And I’m kind of like, well, what are you trying to prove?” he continued. He then pointed to car dealerships that try “to fly the biggest possible flag they can.”

“And it’s like, what are you trying to say here?” Craig said. “It just feels like it’s not just patriotism there, it’s something else.”

Ferguson’s original proposal would have flown the flags only for Memorial Day, Independence Day, the Yarmouth Clam Festival, Labor Day and Veterans Day. Town Public Works Director Karen McNeil suggested leaving them up from Memorial Day through Veterans Day, because putting them up and taking them down repeatedly takes a lot of crew time. Ferguson told the council he would support either schedule.

Craig said the six-month display was a sticking point for him. He said he would be “much more comfortable” if the flags went up only around Memorial Day, Flag Day, the Fourth of July and Veterans Day. He also called 32 flags “a little high” and questioned an early plan to paint the bracket bases red, white and blue.

“My concerns about the project in general have only to do with scope,” Craig said. “It’s not about whether flags are a good idea or a bad idea.”

Earlier in the process, Craig had raised questions about whether the project needed planning approval and whether the town could accept it without a formal gift-acceptance policy, according to Ferguson’s remarks to the council. Ferguson said the town’s planning director had confirmed the project had no planning or zoning implications. He asked the council not to wait for a new gift policy, saying it could push the project past his Eagle Scout deadline.

Other councilors also raised concerns about scope. Councilor Joseph Cooper suggested installing all the brackets but starting with about 20 flags “to see how it looks.”

After about two hours and 25 minutes of debate, the council voted unanimously to approve the project. The number of flags, where they go and how long they fly will be worked out with town staff and reported back to the council at a later meeting. A separate proposal to approve the project with a one-year sunset failed.

“Governing can be messy and difficult,” Craig told Ferguson after the vote. “It’s a public process, and your input helped.”

Maine