Topsfield residents press Select Board on Pride flag policy, accuse member of derogatory remarks
The member said his words at a library listening session were misunderstood, and the board voted 5-0 to adopt a statement on respectful, inclusive conduct.
TOPSFIELD, Mass. — Residents urged the Topsfield Select Board on Monday to adopt a written flag policy that would let the town fly a Pride flag and a larger Juneteenth flag each June, and one speaker accused a board member of using "seriously derogatory language" at a recent listening session.
The board member in question responded during the meeting that he had been misrepresented. "I didn't say anything derogatory to anybody but myself as an adolescent," he said.
The board then voted 5-0 to read into the record a statement affirming its commitment to treating every person with respect, including a pledge to refrain "from language that is purposefully offensive, disrespectful, inflammatory."
Calls for a flag policy
During the public comment period, a resident who said she was a former editor of the Tri-Town Transcript asked the board to have the town fly "a Pride Progress flag and a larger Juneteenth flag during the month of June every year." She said she wanted newcomers to see visual signs that they are welcome and safe, and said that when she saw last year's Juneteenth flag on the side of the gazebo, she "felt embarrassed."
She said other North Shore communities already have flag policies and pointed to the legal concept of government speech in response to concerns that allowing one flag would open the door to others.
A second resident, speaking on behalf of a local human rights coalition, said the group had shared sample policies from neighboring towns over the past year. She asked the board to place a written flag policy on an upcoming regular agenda for discussion and a vote.
Another speaker offered "a different perspective," reading a statement against flying the Progress Pride flag on town property. The speaker said there is an important distinction between welcoming residents and having the town government officially endorse the symbols of particular advocacy movements, and objected to the suggestion that opposing the flags is rooted in bigotry.
"Should we fly the Confederate flag during Confederate History Month in April if requested?" the speaker asked, adding a personal wish to see a pro-life flag flown in October. The speaker urged the board to instead consider a consistent municipal flag policy that represents the entire community.
Accusation and response
A third resident told the board that at a listening session held at the library "not too long ago," there was "a select board member who used some seriously derogatory language." She said she wanted to be sure the town does not condone that kind of speech from people acting on behalf of the government.
After the board's chair read the inclusion statement and a motion was made to adopt it, a board member said he took exception to "the misrepresentation of what I said."
"I said what I said in sympathy and was trying to convey that I had grown from a pre-adolescent to where I am today," he said. "I'm sorry that people didn't see the message I was trying to convey."
The next board member to speak said they had been concerned by the initial reports and had broken protocol to do "a little confidential research," concluding there was "not any malice or hostility" in the remarks. That member said the board chose to issue a general affirmation rather than something aimed at a particular event or person.
Another board member said the statement was not solely a reaction to one incident and "could have been read two months ago" or a year from now.
The board did not discuss the flag policy itself, which was not on Monday's agenda. Late in the meeting, a resident asked what the next steps would be for putting the policy on a future agenda.