Plymouth School Committee weighs policy after speaker hands Bible books to student members
A resident gave the books to the committee and its two student liaisons during public comment. Members said the minors should be off-limits and asked the policy subcommittee to draft a rule.
PLYMOUTH, Mass. — Members of the Plymouth School Committee said Monday they want a policy barring the public from handing materials to the committee's student representatives, after a resident gave them copies of a "Bible promise book" during public comment.
The speaker, the only person to address the committee during the public comment period, told members she had passed out the books to the school committee and the administration. "It is something that can really help us and our students," she said, according to a video of the meeting.
She read from Psalms 33 and 112 and spoke about "the fear of God," which she called "the beginning of wisdom." She closed by saying, "I would encourage the Bible promise book for the students to know some of the Word of God and what God is like and how much He loves them," and thanked the committee.
'It did cross a line'
Near the end of the meeting, a committee member raised the issue under new business, saying the speaker had also given the book to the committee's two student liaisons.
"Because we are school committee members and administrators, so we are technically government employees, I do think that there is a big issue with students being provided with the Bible promise book under basically our care," the member said.
The member said she had stepped out of the room to ask the students whether their parents would be OK with them receiving the books, and told them they were not obligated to take home anything handed to them at a meeting. The students thanked her and took the books, she said.
"Obviously First Amendment exists, and if people want to provide us with this stuff, that's totally fine," she said. "But I feel like it did cross a line when it was provided to our students." She noted that the student liaisons usually attend without a parent present.
Another member said the students should know the handout was "an individual acting on their own accord" and not something the committee supports. Member Christina Bryant said she backed the move "immensely" and noted that members are limited in what they can say during public comment.
Members discussed a rule that nothing could be given directly to the student representatives. "It's nothing against the intent, it's just their students, we're adults," one member said, adding that materials students receive in school are vetted by administrators.
The committee's chair, Luis Pizano, said he would leave the matter to the policy subcommittee but "fully support moving forward with it." No vote was taken Monday.
Also at the meeting, the committee's longest-serving member announced she would step down, with her last meeting set for Dec. 7, citing changes in her household.