Report calls Maine's ranked-choice voting a decade of 'unmet promises,' urges repeal
The Maine Policy Institute says the voting method has not delivered majority winners, higher turnout or cleaner campaigns, and has added delays, ballot errors and recount gaps.
PORTLAND, Maine — Ranked-choice voting has failed to deliver the benefits backers promised when Maine voters adopted it in 2016, and the state should scrap it and return to plurality elections, the Maine Policy Institute argues in a report released Wednesday.
The report, "A Decade of Unmet Promises," was written by policy analyst Montana Towers and updates the free-market group's 2019 study of the voting method, "A False Majority." It concludes that ranked-choice voting has not produced true majority winners, raised turnout, reduced negative campaigning, strengthened third parties or encouraged moderation, while adding complexity, delays and new risks in counting and recounting ballots.
"Maine should repeal ranked-choice voting and restore a uniform plurality system," the report says.
A split system
Maine became the first state to use ranked-choice voting in statewide elections after voters approved it in 2016 with about 52% of the vote, and they kept it in a 2018 people's veto with about 54%, according to the report.
The Maine Supreme Judicial Court found in 2017 that the method conflicts with the Maine Constitution for general elections for governor and the Legislature, and in April the court unanimously ruled that a 2025 bill to expand it would still be unconstitutional, the report says. As a result, Maine uses ranked-choice voting in primaries with at least three candidates and in federal general elections, but plurality voting in general elections for governor, state Senate and state House. The report calls that split confusing and inconsistent.
'Majority' winners
The institute argues that ranked-choice winners often hold a majority only of the ballots still counting in the final round, not of all ballots cast, because ballots that rank no remaining candidate drop out of the count.
In this year's Republican primary for governor, Bobby Charles won about 60% of the ballots left in the final round but about 46% of the roughly 129,400 ballots cast in the first round, according to the report. About 30,000 ballots were exhausted during the tabulation, it says. In 2018, Jared Golden won the 2nd Congressional District with 49.18% of first-round ballots, the report says.
Delays, errors and recounts
Winners of the June 9 primaries were not declared until 10 days later, the report says. In the Democratic primary for governor, Secretary of State Shenna Bellows — whose office runs elections and tabulates ranked-choice races — was eliminated in the second round after trailing Troy Jackson by 548 votes, according to the report. The institute argues that having the state's chief election officer on the ballot raised concerns about impartiality.
Under state law, only candidates in the top three at the end of the next-to-last round may request a recount, so Bellows could not have sought one despite the narrow margin that eliminated her, the report says.
The report also points to administrative problems: drive problems in Biddeford, Bath and Bowdoinham this year that forced ballots to be retrieved and rescanned, about 13,000 ballots omitted in the 2020 primary, and a 2018 survey in which about two-thirds of Maine town clerks said ranked-choice voting added to their workload.
It cites a 2025 study of about 3 million ballot records from Maine, Alaska, New York City and San Francisco that found 4.8% of voters improperly marked a ranked-choice ballot, and that ranked-choice votes were about 10 times more likely to be rejected for an improper mark than votes in choose-one races.
Campaigns and turnout
The report disputes that the method has cooled campaigns, saying political action committees spent about $8.6 million in this year's gubernatorial primaries by June 3, including about $1.8 million on attack ads. On turnout, it says the research is mixed, citing studies that found stable turnout, minimal effects or declines in some places.
Recommendations
The institute recommends repealing ranked-choice voting and restoring plurality elections statewide. If lawmakers want winners to have majority support, it says, they should use a traditional runoff so voters choose directly between the finalists. It rejects amending the constitution to expand ranked-choice voting to all races.
The report comes a week after a ranked-choice tabulation confirmed Republican Paul LePage's win in the 2nd Congressional District, where LePage already held a slim majority of non-blank ballots before second choices were added, The Signal reported.