The New England Signal
Independent journalism covering all six New England states
Maine

Old Orchard Beach council moves to declare fire-damaged Union Avenue building dangerous after five years

The fire chief said firefighters won't go inside unless a life is at risk. The owner's lawyer said the three-unit building is secured and under repair, and that Maine needs the housing.

OLD ORCHARD BEACH, Maine — The Old Orchard Beach Town Council signaled Tuesday that it will declare a three-unit building on Union Avenue dangerous under Maine law, five years after a fire left it vacant, and asked the town's attorney to draft findings for a final decision Dec. 1.

"Based on the evidence we received, we are deeming the building unsafe," Council Chair Shawn O'Neill said after the public hearing. The council cannot formally act until it adopts written findings of fact, the town attorney said.

Town officials: 'not structurally safe'

Code Enforcement Officer Rick Haskell said the building has sat largely as it is since a fire on Oct. 25, 2021, and meets the state's definition of a dangerous building "on pretty much every count," calling it unstable, unsanitary and a fire hazard.

Fire Chief John Gilboy said the building has been open to the elements for most of that time. "My feeling is that building is not structurally safe," he said. He said the address is flagged as a dangerous building in the department's dispatch system, and that firefighters will not go inside unless they believe someone is trapped.

Owner: 'we continue to work on it'

The owner's attorney, Jeff Seltzer of Portland, said the question was the building's condition now, not five years or six months ago. He said the fire damaged only the rear of the building, that an engineer's report found it did not compromise the structure, and that openings have been sealed so no one can get in. A vacant building under construction, he said, is no different from others in town.

The owner said the fire-damaged garage was torn down on time, that he holds active permits for foundation and sprinkler work, and that he had just bought new windows. "I admit that it's been slow," he said, citing trouble finding workers. He said it would not make sense to tear down housing when Maine is short tens of thousands of homes.

Residents who spoke urged the council to act. "I'm hearing the same thing tonight that I heard two months ago," one said. Another said she drives past the building every day on her way to the beach and "it's just sad."

Next steps

Councilor Lori Gramlich said she was inclined to find the building unsafe but wanted written reports from the code officer and fire chief. "I want to make sure that it meets the statutory requirement of dangerous," she said. The attorney said adding new evidence would mean reopening the hearing.

If the council finds the building dangerous, it can order it repaired, secured or torn down within a set time, the attorney said. If the owner doesn't comply, the town may do the work and bill the owner through a special tax on the property.

"They've waited five years," a councilor said of neighbors, asking that the matter come back for action at the next meeting.

Maine