SJC agrees to hear Lindsay Clancy's double jeopardy challenge before March retrial
A single justice sent Clancy's bid to dismiss her murder charges to the full Supreme Judicial Court over prosecutors' objections, with arguments expected in January.
BOSTON — The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court will hear Lindsay Clancy's argument that a second murder trial in the deaths of her three children would violate her protection against double jeopardy, after a single justice sent her petition to the full court Thursday, the Boston Globe reported.
Justice Elizabeth N. Dewar wrote that "a review of the merits" of Clancy's petition by all seven justices is warranted and ordered the case expedited, according to the Globe.
Under the schedule, Clancy's brief is due Dec. 3, the prosecution's Dec. 17 and any reply Dec. 28, with oral arguments set for January unless the full court orders otherwise, WCVB reported. Jury selection for Clancy's retrial remains set to begin March 29.
The arguments
Clancy's lawyers argue that Plymouth Superior Court Judge William Sullivan improperly declared a mistrial in September without questioning a lone holdout juror who kept the jury from reaching a unanimous verdict, WCVB reported. The jury foreperson had told the court the holdout was not following the judge's instructions on reasonable doubt, the Globe reported.
Sullivan rejected Clancy's double jeopardy motion last week, the Signal reported Nov. 9. Her defense filed the petition with the SJC on Monday, the same day Sullivan set the retrial date, according to NBC Boston.
Prosecutors opposed the petition, urging the court to deny it without a hearing, the Globe reported. In an earlier filing in Superior Court, Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague wrote that the judge "properly declared a mistrial due to the manifest necessity after the jury had twice reported that it was deadlocked," and that double jeopardy "does not operate to bar the Commonwealth from seeking justice on behalf of the three victims," Boston 25 News reported.
A spokesperson for Plymouth District Attorney Timothy Cruz did not immediately respond to the Globe's request for comment on the ruling.
The case
Clancy, 36, is charged with first-degree murder in the deaths of her children, Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months, at the family's Duxbury home on Jan. 24, 2023. She has pleaded not guilty, and her lawyers argued at trial that she was not criminally responsible because of postpartum psychosis. Prosecutors contend the killings were premeditated. The charges are allegations, and Clancy is presumed innocent.
Her first trial ended in a mistrial on Sept. 4 after the jury reported it could not reach a unanimous verdict following seven days of deliberations. Prosecutors have said they intend to retry her on first-degree murder charges, the Signal reported Nov. 16.