The New England Signal
Independent journalism covering all six New England states
New Hampshire

Merrimack homeowners can pursue PFOA trespass claim as a class, but not negligence, federal appeals court rules

The 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said homeowners can't pursue negligence claims as a group over contaminated water, but can try as a class to prove the company's chemicals invaded their property.

BOSTON — A federal appeals court has narrowed a long-running class action brought by property owners in and around Merrimack, New Hampshire, who say Saint-Gobain Performance Plastics contaminated their drinking water with PFAS chemicals, but it let them keep pursuing a trespass claim against the company as a group.

In a ruling issued Tuesday, a three-judge panel of the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals reversed a lower court's decision to let the residents' negligence and failure-to-warn claims go forward as a class action. The panel upheld class treatment of their trespass claim and sent the case back to U.S. District Judge Joseph Laplante in Concord.

The homeowners allege that airborne emissions from Saint-Gobain's plant in Merrimack carried perfluorooctanoic acid, or PFOA, onto the ground, where it seeped into groundwater, the town's public water supply and private wells. The plant, on the Merrimack River, made chemical- and weather-resistant fiberglass and films from the 1980s on, according to the ruling. It has since closed and was demolished in 2025, the New Hampshire Union Leader reported.

Why the court split the claims

Writing for the panel, Judge William J. Kayatta Jr. said the negligence claims would require each homeowner to show that the chemical actually harmed their property and that Saint-Gobain's emissions, rather than some other source, caused that harm. PFOA levels vary from property to property, and both the lower court and the residents' own experts acknowledged that other sources may have contributed to contamination in the area, the ruling said.

Those property-by-property questions would overwhelm the issues common to the whole group, the court concluded, so the negligence claims can't proceed as a class.

Trespass is different, the panel said. Under New Hampshire law, the intrusion itself is the injury, so homeowners don't have to show additional harm. If Saint-Gobain caused PFOA to land on class members' property, as the residents' experts contend, the company would be liable for trespass whether or not other sources also contributed, the court wrote. Whether that deposition happened across the class area is a question that can be answered for everyone at once, the judges said.

The court added that damages could still be decided homeowner by homeowner later if Saint-Gobain is found liable.

The panel noted that some courts in other states have refused to treat invisible particles as trespass, and that it knew of no New Hampshire court ruling on the question. Because Saint-Gobain didn't raise that argument, the judges declined to take it up.

Chief Judge David J. Barron and Judge Lara E. Montecalvo joined the opinion.

A decade-old case

The lawsuit was filed in New Hampshire state court in May 2016 and later moved to federal court. It followed a March 2016 announcement by the New Hampshire Department of Environmental Services that Saint-Gobain had found PFOA in water from faucets at the Merrimack plant, according to the ruling.

The state's investigation that followed found PFOA in the Merrimack Village District Water Works system, which serves about 25,000 customers, at levels ranging from undetectable to 141 parts per trillion, and in private wells at up to 1,600 parts per trillion, the court said. At the time, the state's groundwater standard for PFOA was 70 parts per trillion, according to the ruling. New Hampshire has since lowered its drinking water limit for PFOA to 12 parts per trillion, according to the Department of Environmental Services.

Under a 2018 consent decree in a case brought by the state, Saint-Gobain agreed to pay some cleanup costs for certain contaminated properties in Bedford, Litchfield, Manchester and Merrimack. The company did not admit wrongdoing or liability, the court noted.

The class Laplante certified in December 2023 covers people who have owned homes since March 4, 2016, that either get water from the Merrimack Village District Water Works or rely on private wells within a defined area around the plant, including parts of Bedford, Merrimack, Litchfield and Manchester.

The residents are seeking damages for lost property value, the cost of replacement water and cleanup, and interference with the use of their homes. A claim seeking medical monitoring was dropped after the New Hampshire Supreme Court ruled in 2023 that state law doesn't recognize that kind of claim.

The National Association of Manufacturers and the Product Liability Advisory Council filed briefs supporting Saint-Gobain. The American Association for Justice, a trial lawyers' group, filed a brief supporting the residents.

The ruling came 11 days after a Hillsborough County jury awarded $4.36 million to more than 200 Amherst homeowners whose private wells were contaminated by PFOA from the former Textiles Coated Inc. plant, the Union Leader reported.

New Hampshire
Add The New England Signal as a preferred source on Google