The New England Signal
Independent journalism covering all six New England states
Maine

MSAD 60 votes to winterize Lebanon Elementary as town weighs buying a boiler

The school board called it a stopgap while the closure process plays out. A lawyer for Lebanon said the town may hold its own vote on paying for a new boiler.

LEBANON, Maine — The Maine School Administrative District 60 school board voted Thursday to begin winterizing Lebanon Elementary School, the vacant building whose failed boiler has pitted the district against the town of Lebanon.

The board had voted in October not to replace the boiler. It delayed a decision on winterizing at its Nov. 5 meeting after the Lebanon Selectboard asked for two weeks to gather information, The Signal reported. Thursday's vote came at the end of that delay, after several hours of discussion.

One board member who supported the vote described winterizing as a stopgap. It lets the board keep talking with the town for about what heating fuel would have cost, the member said.

Town may vote on a boiler

After the vote, a lawyer representing Lebanon told the board the town is considering a town meeting and a vote to authorize spending money to buy a boiler. If the town gets that authority, it would hope to work with the school board on how the money could be invested and on a long-term plan for the building, he said.

A board member asked how that would work when the district is not ready to turn the building over to the town. The district's attorney said a town meeting vote would not force the board to accept the offer, but that it could be part of the closure discussions.

The board voted Nov. 5 to begin the state's formal process for closing the school. That process requires a report to the Maine Department of Education and a vote by Lebanon residents. The district's attorney said Thursday that preparing the report will likely take "the better part of the winter."

The cost of each option

Ryan Bernier, an owner of Specialty Services, the district's heating contractor, said his company quoted about $13,573 to winterize the building. That covers filling the newer section's hot-water heating system and the plumbing with glycol and draining the steam system in the older section. Bringing the building back into service later would likely cost around $5,000, he estimated, though he said he could not guarantee there would be no damage.

Board members said Specialty Services had offered to refund its roughly $12,000 annual service contract for the building, which would offset most of the winterization cost. Other quotes covered small electric heaters to protect the fire, security and network equipment, along with motion-sensor lighting at the entrances.

Replacing the boiler would be a major job, Bernier said. Crews would have to remove a roof and a window, rig a beam over a stairwell and hoist out eight boiler sections weighing 625 pounds each. A district facilities official said heating the building this winter could cost $50,000 to $55,000 at current oil prices, about double last year's cost.

Town records in the vault

The town's lawyer said the building has served Lebanon for decades as a polling place and meeting space, and that the town keeps its records vault there. One speaker said the records must be kept between 50 and 65 degrees.

District officials said they plan to keep enough heat to protect building systems and will look into heating the vault room. The district's attorney said the board had shown no interest in setting a deadline for the town to move its records out, and that he would not let the board make a decision that put them at risk.

Residents push back

During public comment, residents accused the board of ignoring Lebanon voters. One cited state law requiring school boards to care for and repair school buildings. They argued that moving students out and winterizing the building amounts to closing it without the vote state law requires. A board leader responded that the board was following that exact process.

Another resident said the district had effectively started closing the school two years ago, when it moved students out and called it a reconfiguration.

One school board member, who said they have lived in Lebanon for more than 20 years, told the board they had changed their mind and now believe the board should reconsider its vote and replace the boiler. The member said they had assumed the town did not want the building. They said they had since learned the town is far more invested in it, and that the board should keep it as operational as possible until its future is decided.

MSAD 60 serves Lebanon, Berwick and North Berwick. Lebanon Elementary School has not held regular classes for the past two school years.

Maine
Add The New England Signal as a preferred source on Google