Newton councilor pushes license plate camera moratorium as police chief calls the technology a 'game changer'
Chief Timothy Cohoon told a City Council committee he has no plans right now to bring automated license plate readers to Newton, but warned against a ban.
NEWTON, Mass. — A Newton city councilor called Wednesday for a moratorium on automated license plate readers in Newton, while Police Chief Timothy Cohoon told the same City Council committee the cameras have been "a game changer for policing" and that banning them would go too far.
The Public Safety and Transportation Committee took up a proposal from Councilor Brittany Hume Charm and several colleagues for a possible ordinance giving the council a role in reviewing police surveillance technology before it is adopted. Committee Chair Tarik Lucas said at the outset that no ordinance was up for a vote.
Cohoon said he does not intend to install the cameras for now. "I don't have any plans right now to bring this technology to the city at this time," he said.
'I don't trust the technology'
Councilor Sean Roche said he wants the city to bar the technology outright. "My position is that we should have a moratorium on the implementation of ALPR in our community," he said, citing the growing power of artificial intelligence, data shared across police networks, misuse by officers and what he called the last 22 months of ICE.
Roche said his position is not about the chief or Mayor Marc Laredo. "It's because I don't trust the technology," he said.
He rejected the argument that the council lacks the power to act because police purchasing runs through the mayor. He said a city ordinance can govern how equipment is used even if the council cannot stop it from being bought, and that if the city charter or state law stands in the way, the council could seek a charter change or a home rule petition.
Charm, who presented the proposal, said it "is certainly not about inviting surveillance technology into Newton," and that it is not currently framed as a ban on any one technology. She said Newton does not now use Flock cameras, and that under the current setup the council would not have to be notified if the police department wanted to install them.
Charm said her proposal is modeled on an approach the ACLU promotes, known as Community Control Over Police Surveillance, which she said seven Massachusetts cities have adopted. Under that model, police would bring a proposed use policy to the council for review and approval and file annual reports on how the technology is used. She said concerns about the cameras include data shared with other agencies, including federal immigration authorities asking other police departments to run searches for them.
Chief: 'a step too far'
Cohoon, who became chief in March after leading the Braintree Police Department, said he supports the cameras with safeguards, including mandatory audit trails, short data retention, limits on sharing data with other jurisdictions, and local policies.
"There have been abuses, there has been some things that are unacceptable," Cohoon said. "To throw the baby out with the bathwater, I think, is a step too far."
He described a case in his former community in which he said the cameras helped catch a burglary ring that had targeted the same family twice. He said he welcomes public input, and that his main concern is that any ordinance set "a meaningful safeguard, but without unnecessarily restricting us from keeping the public safe."
Councilors split on the council's role
Other committee members were divided. Councilor Maria Scibelli Greenberg said she wants the council more involved and asked whether the cameras are needed in a city she said ranks among the safest in the country. Cohoon said he views such tools as an insurance policy against rare but devastating crimes.
Councilor Brian Golden said he is wary of adding administrative decisions to the council's workload and wants to be deliberate about whether council involvement is necessary. Councilor Randy Block said he would be more comfortable with regular reports to the council than with a moratorium the council would later have to lift. "I may get there, but I'm not there now," he said.
Councilor Jacob Silber said residents already carry phones that track them everywhere, and said he is no more afraid of the cameras than of his own cellphone.
The committee voted 8-0 to hold the surveillance item and a related item on the police department's progress, which will come back together. The committee's next meeting is Dec. 9.
Earlier in the meeting, Cohoon said a one-year body camera pilot for 12 officers and 12 supervisors is coming soon, pending contract and procurement steps, and that he intends to expand the program after the pilot.