Scituate zoning board OKs home on small lot despite local vote against Question 7
Board members said they struggled to square the variance with Scituate's vote against the ballot question, as Gov. Maura Healey urges lawmakers to pass the idea anyway.
SCITUATE, Mass. — The Scituate Zoning Board of Appeals on Thursday granted a variance to allow a new house on a 5,000-square-foot lot, weeks after voters statewide rejected Question 7, which would have allowed single-family homes on lots that size.
The lot, on Brockton Avenue in the Sand Hills neighborhood, is half the 10,000 square feet the town's zoning requires. The applicant's representatives said nearly every neighboring lot is the same size and that the town had long treated the parcel as buildable.
Board members said they were weighing a change in state law that gives zoning boards more discretion to allow housing against the result of the Nov. 3 vote.
"I think the clear intent of the legislature is to give this board the discretion to do exactly what you said for exactly the reasons you cited," one board member said. "The one issue I'm having a hard time squaring is 60% of our neighbors just said, no, we're fine."
Another member said the ballot vote showed that "the people of this state, certainly the people of this community, said, well, wait a second," and that the board must "figure out what the new normal is going to be."
The board approved the variance on the condition that any house built on the lot not exceed 1,850 square feet of living space. One member said opponents of Question 7 had objected that it set no limits on what could be built.
Statewide debate
Question 7 failed statewide 1,290,724 to 1,258,029, or 50.6% to 49.4%, WBSM reported.
Gov. Maura Healey said Tuesday at the Boston Globe Summit that she would support standalone legislation allowing single-family homes on smaller lots, Boston.com reported.
That push drew pushback at local meetings this week. At the Ayer Zoning Board of Appeals on Wednesday, a speaker reacting to news reports about Healey's comments said, "So much for democracy, huh?"